Navigating Missing Requirements in Girl Scouts

We’ve included some patch suggestions to help your girls learn to be more responsible.

See all our products

1. Provide Structure for Younger Girls

Nancy emphasizes the importance of guidance at the Brownie level. She suggests that leaders send home the requirements via email after meetings. This way, parents are informed about what their daughters need to complete. If a requirement entails special supplies, Nancy advocates for dedicating time in future meetings to revisit those activities. As the girls mature and move on to higher ranks, she notes that communication can shift to the girls taking the initiative to ask about missed requirements.

2. Empower Girls to Take Responsibility

Sara takes a more hands-off approach by allowing the girls to decide if they want to make up missed requirements. She acknowledges that while it’s regrettable when girls don’t engage in homework, she provides the families with what was missed but leaves the responsibility of making it up to them. In her view, Girl Scouts is more about personal growth than adhering strictly to assignments, akin to an academic environment.

3. Establish Clear Guidelines for Earning Badges

Nancy also underscores a crucial point: “Fair doesn’t mean equal.” If girls miss significant activities and do not put in the effort to make them up at home, then they should not receive the badge. She implements a system where girls must provide photographic evidence of their completed work at home. This approach not only emphasizes the educational aspect of the requirements but also discourages the idea of earning badges through mere participation without effort.

4. Create Opportunities for Make-Up Sessions

Deanna shares her experience of offering make-up nights, often in the form of lock-ins. Such sessions can provide an inclusive opportunity for girls to catch up on what they’ve missed. However, she observes a change in attitude as the girls get older; many aren’t as concerned about earning every badge, highlighting a natural evolution in how girls perceive their involvement in scouting.

5. Follow the Lead of Families

Ayme recounts her earlier years as a troop leader where she would actively send home detailed assignments to help girls catch up. However, after noticing a lack of interest from both girls and families, she pivoted her strategy. Now, she might offer suggestions or send emails when asked but acknowledges that ultimately, it’s the parents’ responsibility to encourage their daughters to complete make-up work. As the girls mature, they should also take more initiative in their own scouting journey.

6. Prepare for Increased Responsibility in Older Ranks

From Kari’s perspective, the expectation shifts as girls progress from Brownies to Cadettes. By this stage, the girls should understand that earning badges will require work outside of meetings. She encourages her Cadettes to discuss what they learn at home in subsequent meetings after completing tasks, reinforcing the idea that Girl Scouts is about building a sense of accountability and initiative.